• Tue, Nov 30 2010

Why Alexa Chung Bothers Me

Myspace perfection!!

Last week, Deputy Editor Jennifer Wright wrote a piece on why she irrationally hates Paz de la Huerta. Well, Jen, I see your Paz de la Huerta, and I raise you Alexa Chung, who was conveniently profiled in the New York Times‘ this past Sunday and boy, was it ever annoying.

First off, the tone is relentlessly gushy. Let me just summarize all two pages for you, because unless you really love Alexa Chung, it’s going to be irritating:

Alexa Chung is… (long pause) Alexa Chung!

She… wears clothes. She’s Alexa Chung. Trust us, she’s a huge deal in England, where she can reasonably be called a model and a… fashion fixture! Alexa Chung is a great alternative to people like the Kardashians, who are are famous primarily for showing up on red carpets, have no discernible talent and attach their names to big box clothing lines in order that they may be referred to nebulously as “designers.” Here are some things Alexa Chung says that make her sound entitled. Alexa Chung is hip! You have heard of her!

So that’s the gist of it: Alexa Chung is Alexa Chung and they’re profiling her Alexa Chung-ness.

What’s weird is that the piece keeps insisting that she’s interesting but the author never really endeavors to explain why. Oh, and she’ll soon have a show on PBS entitled Thrift America, in which she rummages and finds remarkable vintage pieces in bargain bins across the country. This makes a lot of sense, because if I were to watch a PBS show on thrift shopping in America, I’d want it to be hosted by a wealthy British person. [Ed. Note: we've followed up with this]

The Times profile does at least touch on the fact that Chung hasn’t really managed to establish herself in America. My guess is because she hasn’t done anything except host a “variety show” on MTV and “collaborate” with Madewell. As for that variety show–It’s On with Alexa Chung–it lasted two seasons before it was canceled. True to the overall gushy tone of the piece, we’re to believe that this is perhaps because Chung is so cool and authentic and above all that Hollywood bullshit.

What?

This is the central problem with Alexa Chung. You cannot style yourself as an “alt” celebrity or some kind of counter culture style icon if you’re just (mildly) famous for afternoon chats with the cast of High School Musical on MTV. And having really long legs.

A bit of full disclosure before we go further, though, as I’ve kind of had it in for Chung ever since her first Madewell collaboration was announced and she issued this gem of stunning obliviousness to the press:

“I was being offered so many collaborations for a long time, but I held off. I thought it would be quite a ‘sellout’ thing to do,” Chung told WWD. “But Madewell had a more organic approach. They seemed really interested in my ideas and it’s a brand that I really admire. Hopefully, the authenticity of this collaboration will be obvious.” [The Cut]

Sellout? SELLOUT? …Girl, you’re a Veejay. “Sellout” would imply you’re sacrificing your credibility or artistic integrity for monetary gain, like bands who sell songs to insurance companies. You aren’t giving anything up. You’re starting from the most vapid kind of commercial success, namely: introducing music videos in babydoll dresses. You are famous for being leggy and wearing clothes people gave you because you look good in them (in all fairness, you do look good in them).

Going back to the Times piece, though, we arrive at Chung herself, who contributes self-congratulatory boasts throughout. When I finally compiled the full list of things she said that annoyed me, I started looking at them together and they made me a little more than annoyed. Here to comment on Chung’s chestnuts, is my Id (represented in caps):

“All of my beauty icons are men,” she said in her throaty alto. “It’s all about effortlessness. It’s all about looking underdone.” YOU WERE A MODEL. MOST PEOPLE PUT IN EFFORT BECAUSE THEY CANNOT MAKE A LIVING OFF THEIR NATURAL GOOD LOOKS.

“I said, ‘I’m going to America and they’re going to try and make my hair shiny and I don’t want it. I want to look like Kurt Cobain.’” YOU ARE COMING TO AMERICA TO HOST A TV SHOW AND BE PAID LOADS OF MONEY TO DO SO, YOU ARE NOT PRESERVING SOME KIND OF DEEP INNER-SWELL OF CREDIBILITY BECAUSE YOUR HAIR IS TWO-TONED.

“I mean I can do it,” she said returning to herself, “but that poise, that A-list Hollywood glamour thing is ugh. It makes me sick.” HOWEVER DO YOU SURVIVE ALL THOSE EVENTS YOU MUST ATTEND? DID THEY CHASE YOU ONTO THE MET GALA RED CARPET WITH BASEBALL BATS? BASEBALL BATS WITH NAILS STICKING OUT OF THEM?

“My style of presenting is, I suppose, a lot different to a lot of female presenters who are usually a prop for the man.” GOD HOW DID YOU GET SO GREAT AT STUFF? YOUR SUCCESS HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH YOUR MODEL-LOOKS AND ABILITY TO WEAR CLOTHES APPEALINGLY.

“A lot of my friends dress like this, and so I feel somewhat bad about how I’ve made a career out of it.” ACTUALLY THIS IS THE FIRST REASONABLE THING YOU’VE SAID.

“And I’m dressing for my body. [But really] it’s just making the most of what personally suits me, which is that I’ve got a long skinny leg and no boobs. So I dress to accommodate that.” WHAT YOU ARE SAYING IS YOU ARE “ACCOMMODATING” YOUR RUNWAY MODEL BODY. I AM GOING TO PUNCH A WINDOW.

Okay, I’m chaining my Id back up to the radiator where it belongs.

Look, I’ll give the woman some benefit of the doubt because practically anyone–not just celebrities–would come off as obnoxious when tasked to talk about herself at length. Unfortunately for Chung, though, a fluffy piece on how great she is (without any solid evidence of great shit she’s done) showcasing her apparent impression that she represents some kind of alt culture does not make her more likeable or interesting.

If anything, Chung is just another example of how beautiful women can become famous for being beautiful combined with the sheer will of their publicists.

Or, in Chung’s case, not really famous at all.

[Photo of Chung by Robert Wright via the Times]

[Also of note: The Fug Girls filed a semi-scathing report on Chung--or at least her handlers'--uppity attitude some time ago that still rankles people, justly]

Share This Post:
  • Fi

    It’s ridiculous that the US is branding her a new style icon. The entire female population of London has been dressing like that for about 4 years x

    http://www.ifyouarenotinfashion.com

  • Tracey

    Love this, great writing. I have no real feeling about Alexa Chung, she does look great in her clothing…but I would too if I was built like her!
    Accessible, everyday style that shines: http://magpiestye.net

  • porkchop

    1. Is your id Owen Meany?

    2. If she shows raids my thrift stores, I’m coming for her eyes.

    • Ashley Cardiff

      1. my id would certainly like to think of itself as an instrument of God

      2. comment of the day

    • Jennifer Wright

      Porkchop, I pray for Ashley every damn day.

  • Talley

    Ahhhh! Thank you for putting words to my feeling of vague uneasiness reading that article on Sunday. As my brilliant mother says every so often, “I hate her and I’ll think of a reason later.”

  • Kat

    She’s not even stylish. She dresses like a little girl.

  • Emme S.

    *standing ovation* followed by numerous *high fives*

  • Milka

    “but that poise, that A-list Hollywood glamour thing is ugh. It makes me sick.” – Alexa Chung. Such a profound, insightful thought and conveyed with the simple use of an interjection: Ugh. Ugh indeed! Her sciolism, vapidness and condescending attitude make me sick.

    And what’s wrong with clean, shiny hair? If she wants to look like Cobain she only needs not shower for, oh, say about a month, that should do the trick. Although, I have the sneaky suspicion that would not be a hardship for Chung since she’s so full of “it” anyways.

  • Steffanie

    Thank you! I thought i was alone in my annoyance of Alexa Chung hahahaha… i just can’t process the fascination.

  • Jen Dziura

    I’ll come out of the closet on this one — I bombed an audition for “It’s On with Alexa Chung,” as I was supposed to make jokes about celebrities, and I made one about Jerry O’Connell (Stand By Me, Sliders, married to Rebecca Romjin), and Alexa didn’t know who he was.

    I’m not saying the joke was funny, mind you. But seriously, how can you host a show about celebrities and never have heard of Jerry O’Connell? He is this person:
    http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0005278/

    I mean, who can forget the fat kid from Stand By Me?

  • Bonnie

    I want to be like Alexa Chung – using my none-too-visible talent and zero accomplishments to get invited to ten parties a night and wear lovely frocks and have a rock star boyfriend who I’ve completely upstaged and who I’ll leave in a couple of years to marry into nobility and then have homes in New York, L.A., etc, which will be filled with the many frocks that keep getting sent to me even though I’m one of the richest women in the world – and I got there just because my legs are so damn skinny and I have a penchant for odd-looking handbags and ass-kissing Karl Lagerfeld! Yay me!

  • Jacques

    This is fantastically written. You actually changed my mind completely about Alexa Chung. I used to think her style wasn’t anything special, but I started to like her when Mulberry made that drop-dead gorgeous bag after her. It’s funny, because when I read the NY Times profile I didn’t get such an awful tone from her, but, rereading your selected quotes, I can totally tell what you mean. I think it must have been hidden in the writer’s gush. You did make one mistake in your short summary, though–the article focused more on how people don’t know her, unless they are from New York City. Because, of course, only those that are socially and culturally above from NYC could have possibly even heard of her. THAT made me sick. (I’m from Illinois, for crying out loud!)

  • nicole

    she dresses like the model version of zooey deschanel.

  • faye

    she seems spoiled and talentless. well said.

  • Haz

    I’m British and I only figured out why people expected me to care about her three days ago. Seriously, people were all ‘Alexa Chung!’ and all I was thinking was ‘who is this woman and why should I care?’.

    I was expecting something more substantial than ‘works for MTV’, I was very disappointed.

    If she annoys you, imagine how much she must piss off British people. It’s people like her that perpetuate American stereotypes about Britain and Britons.

    Shut up, Alexa, there’s nothing alternative about being painfully middle class. I mean, I’m middle class, but at least I have the decency to not be vapid and have an undeserved measure of entitlement.

  • archer

    okay, i sort of understand your point of her not doing that much. but if she has a ‘model body’ and a sense of style, why can people not look up to her? is she annoys you that much, see her as a model, whos actually done some designing and styling. this is a seemingly repetitive and unproductive rant about how shes not a font of all knowledge and wisdom, and actually looks good in clothes.
    please diss people who actually waste space, eg paris hilton, or if your on a model bashing rampant, alessandra ambrosio, who as far as i can tell, is famous for being a vs model and being voted #2 in 99 most desirable women of 2008.

  • Cee

    Am I crazy to think that she often dresses herself rather like an old bag lady?

  • changquangirl

    well written article!! 5stars! i didn’t even know who she was till i started reading this fashion site where they speak of her as if she’s as a goddess! (i don’t watch mtv at all).

  • Josie

    Seriously? Dear Ashley, this is a living, breathing person you’re writing about. This is such a mean and unnecessary article!

  • Georgia

    I’m so glad I’m not alone in my dislike for Alexa Chung! Everything you wrote about, I agree with. I don’t feel you were too harsh, if anything you went a bit easy on her. I find that woman to be unbearable, obnoxious, and her fashion outdated. Thank you for coming out and letting people know how much of an over-rated douche she is!

  • KC

    Great article– so very true. Personally, I don’t mind that she’s semi-famous, I just mind that she seems to think she deserves it.

  • Urja
  • Sarah

    Thank God, I thought I was the only one who thought she was totally overrated and pretentious. Now that I’ve heard what comes out of her mouth that opinion has just increased x 1000!

  • bros

    I never read this site, but when the fug girls linked to it, I knew I had to read it, because anyone who thinks this muppet-faced random, knobby kneed nymph of sherwood forest with a completely paltry resume is lame is a friend to me! Every time I see pictures of her I want to punch her in her smug snout.

  • pj

    i read “i’ve got a long skinny leg and no boobs” and just kept thinking that she only had one leg. i know this is (maybe?) a thing that fashion people say, but it just sounds like she’s dressing to accommodate her one-leggedness. that would actually be tricky.

  • bumbleclut

    Ok, first things first. Americans are the very last people who can criticize having no discernable talent and yet still be famous. They practically invented the concept. Secondly, I feel there is so much PR rubbish spoken by celebrities that when you hear a minor one actually try and appear genuine – it grates, no two ways about it. Thirdly – on a personal note, try having a flat chest your whole life and be thrilled about it, simply because models do too. In real life you get endless comments about looking like a boy and never EVER finding pretty bras to fit! Ok I’m done now!

    • Natasha

      “Americans are the very last people who can criticize having no discernable talent and yet still be famous. They practically invented the concept.”

      ^ 100% correct. One of the biggest hypocritical ideas in this “article”.

    • Ashley Cardiff

      I’m kind of unclear on this. Just because America allegedly invented a concept, suddenly all Americans are incapable of criticizing it?

  • Jax

    Too much is being made of this and her. But in short, the media like her because she is refreshing compared to lots of other starlets and actresses. You can argue she belongs in the same camp as Michelle Williams, Maggie Gyllenhaal, and Kirsten Dunst. But still even in that group, she is refreshing.
    It is funny to me that she’s getting commended for dressing like thousands of other hipsters in SF’s Mission District and Brooklyn and Silverlake.

  • Snoo

    This is hilarious! Completely hits the nail on the head.

  • cynthia

    honestly, i don’t even think she’s pretty. she’s so thin she looks sick. and her legs look like sticks.

  • annebeth

    I never used to be a fan of her because she did seem to come out of nowhere, being famous for being famous and all that jazz, but then it dawned on me: she’s an IT girl. Who cares if these girls don’t have something “real” that motivates them being famous. Seriously, most actresses are interchangable too and only “known” for fitting a certain type of beauty standard. Alexa is a girl that seems to appeal to a lot of girls out there, stylewise and imagewise. We don’t need to see her present/act/design/whatever, she’s just a person that inspires. Much like Edie Sedgwick. People don’t have to have “talent” to be famous or to deserve their fame in my opinion, they just need to appeal to people. At least Alexa’s appeal is a positive one. It irks me a lot more when people become known because the public basically hates them, like the Kardashians or Paris Hilton.

    Go Alexa! Just be you and inspire girls who are still looking for their identity!

    PS: I’m sick of “normal” size girls complaining about skinny girls. Last time I checked, most guys prefer normal girls to anorexic looking chicks like Alexa, and being very skinny isn’t easy at all. All young girls have issues about the way they look. I’m not as skinny as Alexa, and I still was horribly insecure about my skinny legs and lack of boobs or butt up until I was 19 or something. It isn’t “easier” to be stick skinny than to be normal sized.

  • CynthiaRose

    Thought the deal was holding on to Gwynnie/Gloop, returning Madonna with Alexa and Cat in lieu of Air Miles?? Sorry America did we get that wrong?

    • AK74

      You can have Gwynneth forever; we can handle Cat but we’d like to return Alexa, please. The last time we had this kind of celebrity exchange, I believe we traded you David Gest in exchange for Heather Mills. Not sure WHO was the winner there…

  • Alexandra

    I agree with ‘BumbleClut’ as in 99% of Americans dont really get the right to critique someone for being famous for being famous. Looking at people such as The Kardashians, Holly Madison, Paris Hilton and Lauren Conrad who all became famous for doing nothing and being pretty it quite amusing that you consider Alexa to be one of these people.
    Alexa Chung started out as a young model, then started a career in presenting tv shows (wining best presenter twice), shes also had radio shows, write colums and articles for newspapers and magazines and was named a contributing editor to British Vogue. She also does a lot of charity work.
    I personally don’t have Alexa Chug on an idolising pedestal, but there are much much worse role models. Of course everyone is entitled to their own opinion but saying that Alexa does nothing is definatley false. I frankly think that that its incredibly rude to discredit people because they haven’t made a big impression in your world, she’s big news over here in Britain but of course that isn’t important.

  • Aly

    Question: Why do you feel the need to write such rude and negative articles?
    Does it boost your own self-esteem to critique people you’ve never (and probably won’t ever) meet? Just because Alexa Chung isn’t a big enough star in America for you doesn’t mean that she isn’t well-known for her work and charitable giving in other places in the world. And, excuse me, but why are you railing on her for her “model body”? It’s no more her fault that she has a gorgeous body than it is your’s for having a normal one; it’s GENES. She dresses in a way she enjoys and feels confident in, just like we all try to do.
    And yes, her style of presenting IS different than the majority of women on television. It’s not that she’s trying to be some beloved cult figure, but that she’s sticking with a style that represents her personality.
    Leave the bashing to Perez Hilton or some other trashy site. Instead use the time to gain some self-confidence and tolerance.

    (Oh, and to other commenters on the article: Please don’t generalize when talking about Americans. It gets really annoying, especially to one who’s a fan of Alexa Chung. We’re not all haters.)

  • Aly

    Sorry, meant to put “gorgeous” in quotes. Beauty is different to everyone.

  • Luna

    Has anyone seen her old column, ‘Girl About Town’ that she wrote for the British newspaper, The Independent? Her articles are the definition of vapid. Oh the perils of getting free clothes and going out every night! :P

  • Adrienne

    Seriously? I’m pretty sure that Alexa Chung has never marketed herself as being an ~alternate~ to people like the Kardashians or the Hilton sisters. She is just different and quite frankly, honest. I just don’t understand why you do not seem to able to discern the validity of her words. She does dress for herself. Why are you criticizing the way she looks? It’s how she looks. Just because there is some sort of force in society that is saying there should be “normal-sized” people everywhere doesn’t mean that skinny girls are getting it any easier. They’re alternately being pressured to change their image and “eat,” and yet the prevalent image of the beautiful woman is one that is emaciated–which, I should contribute, is not what Alexa is compared to other models. Even if she is whatever, “self-congratulatory” as you say it, so what? How would you even know? Honestly, you’re grasping at straws by analyzing her words to the point where you’re simply taking it all out of context. She’s just out there, and she’s just different, the way Maggie Gyllenhaal, Emma Watson, Michelle Williams–those “type” of girls are different. They don’t market themselves as different, they just are. I just don’t understand why you proclaim to have a particular problem with her being famous for doing “nothing.” You may as well be speaking about any other celebrity gracing the cover of more than half of the magazines on newsstands right now. Your problem with her is actually with the way she looks, and that, quite frankly, is sad.

  • tom

    If you’d actually read the article you’d have understood her issue is not with how she looks (this column would not even exist if she didn’t like pretty girls, ffs), but her high-horse attitude that she’s somehow different and more talented than other telly presenter chicks, which she has yet to prove.

  • eryn

    Have never really put much thought into Alexa Chung but you definitely seem to have hit the nil on the head given the quotes from the article. She sounds paiiiiiinful.

  • Natasha

    I saw this posted on The Fashion Spot and, speaking as a writer/journalist myself, this article is genuinely terrible. I don’t really get why this was posted here when it is entirely the kind of shit to be reserved for the author’s cheesy blog. The only reasonable thing in the article: “practically anyone–not just celebrities–would come off as obnoxious when tasked to talk about herself at length.”

    The whole article just screams irrational jealousy and ranting taking the place of what I personally experience as admiration for a beautiful, well-dressed girl. Yes, I am a fan of Alexa, but my criticism of this article comes primarily from I first said in this comment, not even beginning to touch on where you’re wrong about her career.

  • jdnsc

    I agree with those commenters who mentioned that being skinny (aka having no discernible breasts and ass) is very difficult too and can make you feel ugly and jealous of those who are average-sized, the same way chubby or overweight people can feel.

    And god knows it’s difficult to find nice-fitting clothes when you have no curves whatsoever and basically look like a 12-year old girl. So I totally understand what Alexa was referring to when she mentioned finding the right type of clothes for a skinny body.

  • sadie

    you hit the nail on the head here! I found myself getting really annoyed while reading the Times piece and couldn’t put my finger on why. bless you for getting to the bottom of it so brilliantly.

  • Ally

    What has she done? She modelled for six years, and then worked on TV for about four years after that. Also, in a sea of girls desperate to be photographed, her styling is an original standout. She’s honest and fairly unassuming in discussing that experience. I don’t know why this is so baffling and off-putting, besides bland envy.

    But there seems to be some sort of good-girl kabuki dance that Americans like to see their young female celebrities do, and apparently Alexa doesn’t know the moves. Your writing is funny, but ultimately spiteful and vacant.

    As to the Fug girls item, no high-fashion person wants to be in the weeklies, which are the very definition of tacky notoriety, and I’ve seen the outfit Alexa Chung wore to that show featured admiringly in dozens of magazines over a period of months. No suprise that the Fug girls failed to appreciate it in real time. They’re pretty funny, too, but overall seem to favor a Doris Day fashion sensibility that goes well with the aforementioned American good-girl kabuki. The commercial appetite for that sort of non-threatening appearance is what makes the tenor of Alexa’s style so appealing to less-conformist women.

    • Ashley Cardiff

      I’m not really sure you know what kabuki means.

  • Janice Second

    I work at a music venue and we had Arctic Monkeys play. She dates the lead singer so she was there and she was very friendly and sweet. We even all went out together after the show to grab a drink. She was very nice. I have no idea why she is “famous” though…

  • AK74

    I am an American who used to live in London, which is where I first heard of her. The thing that bugs me about her–which I suppose is not her fault–is that in the UK fashion magazines, they practically shoved her down your throat as some kind of fashion icon. But she wears the EXACT same outfit constantly! Baby-doll dresses with those dumb shootie things. She has nice legs and can pull it off–good for her. But she shouldn’t be hailed as some fashion pioneer when she basically revised the Courtney Love look and has worn it more or less every day as long as she’s been famous.

  • Rachel

    I had never heard of her until about 10 minutes ago, but after reading your pieces + the piece in the Times, I completely agree. What a waste of celebrity. I still don’t know who she is or why we care.

  • roland

    i agree w/ you completely. alexa chung should not be paid any attention. seriously what the fuck has she done? there’s no talent, sorry alexa, but just because you look good, how long will that last? being a true artist you have to shout your art to the world so they will pay attention but just because you look ok or half chinese will people really give a fuck. plus w/ models they have to work hard to stay on top. so does she have that it factor, she’s one of those celebs that are just there…

  • Getoveryourself

    Jealous much? This article was as much a waste of time as that Times article probably is.

  • ccak

    you have issues.

  • JF

    I have no opinion on A. Chung, but this sounds like it was written by a jealous fat person. I’m kind of embarrassed for you, Ashley Cardiff. There is just no point to this article. These sound like thoughts that are best kept inside your own head, or between you and your girlfriends. Because yeah.. you sound bitter and fat.

    • datsun

      lol. and you sound like “A. Chung’s” personal assistant.

    • Sara

      Seriously… anyone who has this much animosity for someone they’ve never met has some personal shit to work out

    • Ashley Cardiff

      @Sara and what kind of personal shit does one have when compelled to dig up every old article on this site that relates unfavorably to Alexa Chung and comment on it?

  • Catherine

    I totally agree with the general gist of “who the hell is Alexa Chung, anyway?”. I keep seeing this name in fashion and celebrity news articles, and I never quite understand WHY she’s famous or what her contribution has been. She’s pretty-ish, but kind of plain as models go. She’s not exceptionally stylish, she’s not controversial, she’s not really doing much right now…. I just don’t get why she’s suddenly everywhere. I don’t begrudge her success, but I can’t quite tell what sort of success it is that she’s having.

  • Emma

    WELL DONE for finaly stepping up and saying what we have all been thinking of for the past year. Who is Alexa Chung, What has she done apart from wear designer clothes and be the person on the TV who says ‘and now its time for Friends’. I dont understand why when people see a pretty face they all of a sudden put them in every fashion magasine, ( i personaly dont even think she looks that pretty).
    Instad of filling magazines with mindless picters of skinny, dumb girls they should write about the truely inspiering people, the ones who are actualy talented and have worked hard to get where they are.