Bullish: What to Do About Being (Temporarily) Pretty

Nobody stays pretty forever, so if you’re currently propping up your career with your looks, it’s time to slowly, gently, wisely transition into what I like to call a “brain-based economy.”

How can you tell if you’re propping up your career with your looks? The hostesses at my (otherwise) favorite Wall Street restaurants certainly seem to be — the more your effectiveness is predicated on your appearance, the more you resent when (oh no!) women customers arrive, and your not-so-secret weapon is no longer effective! Another good clue is whether you strongly prefer to do business in person to on the phone; while there are other perfectly legitimate reasons for such a preference, some attractive people dislike phones because, “Dammit, if they could just look at me, they would totally do what I want!”

I’m not saying that there’s anything wrong with persuading people in person — far from it. I’m just saying that it probably won’t last forever. So, I’d like to talk about what to do with The Pretty while you’ve got it, and how to prepare for when The Pretty disperses like so much fairy dust.

When I was twenty-four, I woke up one day and discovered that my cheekbones had come in. That was nice. I appeared in an ill-fated charity calendar, modeled logo underpants for my friend’s business, and walked in a few indie fashion shows in Brooklyn. That year, I made $17,000 and also participated in medical studies for money. In my brief forays into attending casting calls, I met women much more attractive (and taller!) than I, and formed the conclusion from talking with them that beauty can be a magic ingredient that helps a career in some unrelated field, but beauty alone rarely translates into real money unless you truly are in the top 0.0001%.

Here are some better ideas:

Spend The Pretty Where It Has More Currency

Say you’re pretty good looking — not like a model, but compared to the people around you. If you try to make a living based on your looks, people will pick you apart. You will always be too short or your legs too fat or too generic or something else. Call yourself a “model” and other women will cut into you like Ginsu knife salesmen into a wooden block used as a demonstration tool to sell Ginsu knives. Do not try to compete directly on being pretty. If you make a big deal out of your appearance, people will look for your flaws, in much the same way that the quirky earlobes or oddly-shaped toes of your ex were once something you found endearing and, now that you dislike that person, are something that seems like a Gollumesque deformity.

So, if you find yourself in the position of being more attractive than average, and wondering if maybe you should try your hand at the entertainment industry instead of what you’re doing now, I’d suggest otherwise. The best piece of advice I ever heard on this score is: If you’re attractive, go into a field full of less attractive people, and pretend you don’t know that you’re attractive.

Know Your Audience

As a child, I read an Ann Landers column that I haven’t been able to find in any online archive, but as I remember it, a young woman wrote that she was just too beautiful for her job (in a law firm, I think): she felt the excessive attention from men and resentment from women, and it was holding her back. So she went to a department store makeup counter and asked how she could look more … plain. I think it involved a dusting of powder in the general eyebrows/eyelashes region, causing her features to not — as they say — “pop.” It worked, and everything was grand (and, of course, she could still look gorgeous evenings and weekends). After the column ran, a number of people wrote in saying they didn’t believe the story was real, and that is was very important to be as beautiful as possible all the time.

Is that true? In November, a study came out reporting that attractive women who attached photos to their resumes (a common practice in Europe and Israel) received fewer callbacks for interviews than applicants who had attached “plain” pictures or no pictures at all. The authors speculated that female HR workers were responsible for the discrimination (attractive men received more callbacks than “plain” or no-picture guys). However, once you get the job, the relationship seems to be reversed — attractive women earn 4% more than their less-attractive peers.

4% is actually a pretty small variation considering, of course, the much larger variation present across all different types of jobs and levels of experience. And in the photo-on-the-resume study, hiring managers reported that part of their reaction to a candidate was based on the decision to send in a photo in the first place; maybe a beautiful woman is fine, but a beautiful woman showing off isn’t. Those things are different.

But I also wonder if the effect is different based on job function — if you were hiring a woman to sit in the cubicle next to you and work on publishing rights all day, maybe you would be unduly annoyed if she were too hot. But if you were hiring a woman to sell enterprise software, and the success of the company depended on the performance of the salespeople, then dear god, you’d take her as hot as you could get her. In other words, maybe it’s possible to be inappropriately hot for an office — but be perfect for representing the company to the world. Let others make money off your hotness and your hotness is more likely to be embraced by your colleagues.

I also thought about women I’ve worked with and whether any had rubbed me the wrong way (not that I would act on those crotchets, but everyone has gut reactions). Two women came to mind. One was pleasant-looking and athletic, frequently found in corduroys and sweater vests, and didn’t seem to wear any makeup. I liked her instantly. (That sentence kind of sounds like the start of some lesbian erotica, but really, it was totally professional.) The other looked a bit like a Real Housewife of Beverly Hills — about 40, processed blonde hair. The thing that made me cringe when I saw her was her very high and brightly-colored heels. She was wearing them with businesswear and it wasn’t exactly sexy — just unnecessary. So much of fashion is a display of dominance over other women. Want to make other women dislike you? Wear Louboutins when you’re not at a party.

Everyone prefers to look at people with symmetrical features and clear skin. But beyond that, know your audience. For a variety of perspectives on dressing femininely (or not) at the office, see this post on The Glass Hammer.

Share This Post:
    • marissa

      Great article. I find that too many girls self-confidence in general is based on the amount of attention they get for being pretty. When I got in my mid-twenties I realized that I better do something more fulfilling than being pretty or else I would feel worse and worse about myself every year.

    • Leah

      I know this was suppose to be about the pretty thing, but the part about making a portfolio is the best idea I’ve ever heard. As a 20something who is always on the prowl for a better opportunity, I’m definitely going to do that.

    • Thaler

      Greta Guttman didn’t last past the pilot, though. That’s showbiz!