But only bake lust foods. So, oysters and spanish fly, and I have no idea where you go to get spanish fly. Basically just only serve him oysters, massive heaps of them. Here's hoping he's not allergic.
Bunnies are the right idea, but bunnies do not do it for every single person. During the day, unobtrusively ask him what his favorite animal is. Then appear in the middle of the night, wearing the garb of that animal.
Be able to transform yourself into any being in the world! Be Angelina Jolie! This is the picture that comes up on wikipedia when you google "shape shifter," weirdly!
Not like "be bewitching." Actually use spellcraft. Historically this is supposed to be effective.
It's the only thing you can really do.