It’s been an exciting/stupid year for Ali Lohan (little sister to Lindsay, child of Dina), who announced her plans to become a model, promptly lost a lot of weight and then came under fire for maybe drastically altering her face with cosmetic surgery. Now she’s coming under fire for that weight loss, which appears to have gone a little more extreme. Namely:

We tend to give famous women the benefit of the doubt when it comes to things like this–people speculate about their weight all day long without any insight into their health–but we’re talking about the Lohans. And Ali looks thin.

Best case scenario, Ali’s weight and diet are being monitered. Worst case scenario… by Dina.

(Photos via TDM)