BB creams don’t care about black people. Yeah, hear me out.
I’m always late on the big beauty bandwagons because I often revert to my middle school self who liked to think she hated anything mainstream. But I’ll admit, the BB cream hype was slowly working its magic on me, even though I had no idea what it really was. For those of you who are still a little stumped, a BB cream is a “beauty balm” that acts as a foundation, primer and moisturizer. All those tedious steps in your morning makeup routine replaced with a single product sounds great, right? Why wouldn’t I at least want to try it out?
But then I noticed something strange: As I checked out these glorified tinted moisturizers at the drugstore, I noticed that they didn’t seem to come in many shades. In fact, the only shades offered were 50 shades of light and white. Oh, and maybe one ashy looking tan. The only one that didn’t suck was Iman’s line, which is specifically geared toward women with darker complexions anyway.
I took to the internet, asking my Tumblr followers if they had any BB cream recs. The response was unhelpful to say the least. I was either told what I already knew–that BB creams rarely come in darker tones–or they hand waved western BB creams entirely and suggested that I get a legit one from Korea.
Now, I’m not doubting that BB cream formulas in Korea might be a cut above the stuff I would get at Target, but something tells me that if I’m having enough trouble finding a BB cream color to match my [insert brown confection of your choice] complexion here, I’m not going to have much luck in Korea.
Honestly, other than Iman‘s line and a few CoverGirl gems, I’ve rarely put much faith in drugstore makeup to match my coloring. So I turned to more familiar turf–high-end cosmetics–to see if they were a little more forgiving.
Well, I did a quick swatch test of some of the most popular BB creams at Sephora and the results were both surprising and disappointing.
From top to bottom:
Smashbox BB Cream
Clinique CC Cream (that was an accident, actually)
Bobbi Brown BB Cream
Too Faced BB Cream
Tarte BB Cream
Dior BB Cream
Clinique BB Cream
The variety of darker shades were lacking in nearly every single brand I checked out. Too Faced and Tarte were particularly blinding. Seriously, they should just have a sign stating that their BB creams don’t cater to anyone darker than a stack of Pringles. Too Faced‘s BB cream names only emphasized it: Snow Glow, Vanilla Glow, Linen Glow, Creme Glow and Nude Glow. Sheesh, I guess they looked up any and all synonyms for white.
As much as Sephora praises their Smashbox BB cream and despite how popular it is, the range left me only a little impressed. I mean, kudos to at least having a couple of kind of dark tones, I guess. But I’m not going to pat someone on the back for that, especially when other brands who have included a darker color seemed to have gone about it in a similarly careless way. For example, look at the jump between colors here for Clinique‘s BB cream line, which includes a new shade that wasn’t available in store at the time…Yikes.
For the record, their CC cream line is quite robust in terms of color options. Why? No clue.
The real winner was both surprising and not that surprising at all: Bobbi Brown. They’ve always had a good–or, rather, realistic–range of colors for all of their foundation and concealers, and their BB creams are no exception. The dark colors varied in undertone as well, which is a huge plus. So why am I surprised? Because I haven’t heard anybody else raving about it. Even the Sephora employee who helped me seemed surprised by Bobbi Brown’s BB cream line.
So my conclusion is that both drugstore and high-end brands suck at offering BB creams for darker tones. This shouldn’t be shocking for those of us who have always struggled with finding a makeup color that doesn’t completely wash us out, but that doesn’t make it any less disappointing. Even if you think BB creams are a waste of money, those of us with darker complexions should be able to waste our money too.