Shine says that it’s a beauty fail, and that:

Whitney Port’s super shiny and dark complexion doesn’t even come close to making it look like she just stepped off a tropical island getaway. Instead, it looks extremely fake and very out of season for winter.

Which, well, okay. I mean, I guess if you want veracity, everyone would be going around with really pale skin. But really, while I think she looks kind of shiny here, I also think that could just be because a flashbulb just went off in her face. She doesn’t look that terrifying orange Julius color that some celebrities do, so I’m giving her a pass. Do you wear bronzer our of season?