When we’re shopping for makeup, we typically have a clear idea about what we want whether it’s a flattering neutral lipstick, a soothing moisturizer or something highly Instagrammable. Sephora is going to make you flip your usual beauty shopping habits with the launch of its Sephora Favorites mystery makeup kits.

(Related: Winky Lux Launched Purrrrrfect Cat Face Lipsticks)

According to Glamour, a savvy Sephora shopper in Germany under the handle @whitepolkydots spotted the mystery sets. Photos reveal that there are three versions: a silver package for lips, a gold package for eyeliner and a rose gold package for cheeks. @makeuphunternews and @trendmood1 report that the mysterious sets are part of the Holiday 2018 collection and will cost $16 each.

View this post on Instagram

More #Holidays2018 Maddness!!! 🚨#SPOTTED ✨❄️🎁 in stores @sephora #cute #SephoraFavorites Sets $16 Each: 1. Mystery Lip Kit – #KVD everlasting liquid lipstick, #BiteBeauty lipstick, 1 mystery makeup, 1 pin 2. Mystery Eyeliner Kit – #Stila stay all day liquid eyeliner, #KVD Tattooliner, mystery makeup, 1 pin 3. Mystery Cheek Kit – #Nars orgasm blush, #Bobbibrown bronzer, mystery makeup, 1 pin #ByeByeMoney Baby! 💸💸💸 Who will be going to find these in stores ? ❄️✨🎁 XO #Trendmood #sephora pic: @whitepolkydots THANK U for this beautiful update: @makeuphuntersnews 😘 . . . #motd #makeupoftheday #mua #ilovemakeup #makeup #makeupaddict #makeuplover #makeupblogger #makeuponpoint #onpoint #makeuplook #makeuplove #makeuptalk #makeuptutorial #makeuplover #makeupaddict

A post shared by TRENDMOOD (@trendmood1) on

If you’re someone who prefers to be completely surprised, stop reading now. If you cannot stand the suspense and want to make sure that you get your money’s worth from the kits, it’s reported that the Mystery Cheek Kit contains a NARS Orgasm Blush, a Bobbi Brown Bronzer and a pin. The Mystery Eyeliner Kit has a Kat Von D Tattooliner, a Stila Stay All-Day Liquid Eyeliner and a pin. Finally, the Mystery Lip Kit has a Bite Beauty Lipstick, Kat Von D Everlasting Liquid Lipstick and a pin. What’s more, the kits also contain some *mystery* makeup.

(Related: Introducing Kaja, The First K-Beauty Brand To Be Co-Developed With Sephora)

There’s no official release date for the mystery kits from Sephora. Given that other brands are launching their Holiday 2018 collections, we can hopefully see the Sephora Favorites mystery kits hitting the shelves soon.