We were pretty charmed by Twilight star Kristen Stewart‘s most recent red carpet appearance: back at her hand and footprint ceremony, she decided to pair checkered slip-on Vans with her cool Marios Schwab mini. Now, Breaking Dawn has premiered in LA (already?) and we must mull over her statement-making J. Mendel gown.

Here’s what we like: the abstract geometric pattern set off by the black band at the waist, how the crew neck balances out the thigh slit, how the colors are fantastic on her, and how comfortable she looks. We even think the beauty (especially the eyeshadow) is perfect. For some reason, though, we’re not sure if it all comes together.

What do you say? It’s a soaring success or not quite right?

Also. We give the people what they want:

(Photos via Getty)