So, One Day came out and people have mixed feelings. You know what else they have mixed feelings about? Anne Hathaway’s white Alexander McQueen dress at the film’s London premiere. For one, some may wonder if this is an awkward length on her? Too short? Too long? Too flounced?

Part of me really likes this dress and the pretty throwback silhouette. The other part of me thinks the shoes are woefully mismatched and the piles of jewelry on her wrist feel very grandma-ish, which sinks the overall look. Let’s discuss!

[b5poll id=”5bdcfa163e76430a977a77c515533889″]

(Photos: Getty)