A while back, rumors were swirling about Jessica Simpson having bought her own engagement ring. Now that there’s talk of she and beau Eric Johnson eloping, it’s bringing it all back up for us…

And so we want to know — would you ever buy your own engagement ring? Now, be honest here. I know that the temptation is to jump in all angry and be like, “it doesn’t matter who pays, as long as there’s love, we both pay it anyway if it’s financed [ed. note: that’s actually a legitimate point], if I have more money I don’t care,” etc. etc.

And in theory, sure. We agree.

But theory and feelings don’t always match up, so if that’s not how you feel, you can tell us. This poll is anonymous, we swear.

[b5poll id=”5c9cd1658220e067d52ae8473073f42d”]